A sequence of seven images showing a dinner party, joined hands, a person in a hat, a picture frame, lemon juice, a bun.

P2YL | 8. Is there such a thing as 'The One'?

Katrina Robinson • 25 November 2023
Image of a woman holding a Lumio light.

There is one question which crops up regularly about love, relationships, and marriage.


‘Do you think “The One” exists?’ 


‘Well…I do know “A One” exists. And that’s even better.’


The difference?


I’ve had my experience of meeting The One. It happened one summer morning in a way that felt like, er, divine guidance. Don’t laugh. You can read about it here.


For the purposes of stats, we were together for sixteen years, married for fourteen, but towards the end of that time my husband began an affair with another married woman, and left me to marry her. 


So was ‘The One’ a myth? 


I’ve written elsewhere of the devastating sense of betrayal and abandonment you get when the husband or wife you married in good faith as 'The One' opts out.


That wise-woman of the human soul, author Dorothy Whipple, describes the feeling of utter incredulity, in Someone At A Distance:


'The man who had knelt beside her bed, that night their first child had been born,

he couldn't be doing this to her, could he?


'Could he?'


But perhaps an even bigger disillusionment took place in all that I had previously believed about relationships, listening to one’s intuition, and the idea of any sense of guidance or destiny.


Was ‘The One’ a myth? 


Even now, I don’t actually think so. I’m a bit religious and I know what people mean when they get a strong sense that God or Fate or Destiny or whatever you want to call it is playing some part.


But life and human nature being what it is, even with The One, you or they can still be tempted away or bored or irritated or not feel like working through issues or going off with someone else at some stage in your life together.


‘The One’ can feel idyllic, but isn't a guarantee.


My firm belief is that this doesn't mean there is only one person on the planet meant for you and otherwise you will be on your own.


'A One'


Instead I believe in something even better.


A One.


That’s all it takes: one person who is committed to you and you to them. I met my lovely second husband in midlife and got married in my fifties. And we didn’t meet in any particularly magical way. Both divorced, each of us hoped to love and marry again someday, so we prioritised the search. Joined groups. Socialised. Made an effort. Dated. Worked on ourselves. For a number of years. Persevere and persist and it will happen. 


And having a cherished partner by your side supporting you through life's challenges is a huge blessing. It's important not to constantly think there is always going to be someone more perfect out there. 


So this is how I define The One these days.


It’s The One you commit to and who commits to you. 


New Title

New Paragraph

Woman in black hat and green-patterned Agnès B top, holding a hand of playing cards and a drink.
by Katrina Robinson 18 April 2026
Tips on midlife online dating that got me from Devastated Divorcée to Serenely Married.
A monochromatic blue oil painting shows a distant shoreline with faint lights reflecting on calm, hazy water at twilight.
by Katrina Robinson 19 March 2026
?. The comfort zone | When 'the worst' has happened how can you find simple daily measures to survive those first few weeks?
Part 2 of a guide about love life. Phone with
by Katrina Robinson 6 March 2026
A handy guide to why you need to date differently second time round PLUS The books and films that help you make it work for you.
by Katrina Robinson 8 February 2026
Part 2 Of Your (Love?) Life is dedicated to * Reclaiming love and feminine confidence * Often after divorce or heartbreak * Or simply appreciating a feminine boost *
A three-part infographic showing a person’s progress from surviving, to thriving, to passing on what they have learned.
by Katrina Robinson 23 January 2026
I show you ways to comfort yourself when going through divorce or loss, and how the clothes you wear can lift your mood. Katrina Robinson. Part 2 Of Your (Love?) Life.
A person lying face down under a doormat that reads
by Katrina Robinson 22 December 2025
Next in the series: Five ways my Part 2 wedding was different from Part 1
Text says
by Katrina Robinson 1 December 2025
2) Big party or select do? 🎊
A speech bubble contains the text,
by Katrina Robinson 7 November 2025
Learning to shake off the flawed and flaky
Two photos of the same person—a wedding portrait and a headshot—beside a silhouette of a person blowing dandelion seeds.
by Katrina Robinson 25 October 2025
1) Live together or not? 🤔
A collage of Diane Keaton featuring photos of her in hats and dark clothing, with a 1977 New York postmark in the center.
by Katrina Robinson 21 October 2025
In the wake of the sad news of the loss of Diane Keaton (1946–2025), we revisit her standout style persona in 'Annie Hall'
More posts