A sequence of seven images showing a dinner party, joined hands, a person in a hat, a picture frame, lemon juice, a bun.

P2YL | 45. Red Carpet women don't wear shoulder-bags

Katrina Robinson • 1 September 2025

And what that means for girls like us

A line of people in formal evening wear stand on a red carpet in front of Golden Globe backdrops.
A button labeled

Perhaps it was going through the shock of divorce all those years ago that made me want to up the ante in the style-stakes. 


I believe a man ultimately falls in love with the essence of who a woman is, but it is her appearance he notices first.


I like making an effort in how I look ⎯ for myself, for my husband, and for other people ⎯ so the aesthetics of being a woman will always interest me.

 

Seeing how other women put their clothes and appearance together is for me part of the learning-process.



Style-watching on holiday

Holidays are great opportunities for seeing and learning from other women’s personal style as most of us like to dress our best on holiday. It adds to the festive feeling. 


This year, on holiday, sitting with my husband over after-dinner drinks in the bar of a classy hotel in the West of Ireland, I was in prime style-watching position.


The Powder Room Derby

A gentle stream of stylish women passed in front of us through the bar on their way to the terrace or ladies’ room.


Sipping my Old Fashioned (I’m a fan of Mad Men) I began to notice one detail over and over again.


By the end of the evening I had decided I wanted to change one of my wardrobe habits.


The Curse of the Shoulder-Bag

A person in a floral dress adjusts their hair while carrying a brown leather tote bag on a sunny city street.

In this formal luxury environment most women wore stylish dresses but sometimes their appearance was spoilt by accompanying it with a daytime shoulder bag.

Why shoulder-bags and evening dresses don't always work

Symmetry is part of what the human eye interprets as beauty. Slinging a bag over one of your shoulders bisects your appearance by digging into the shoulder-line, interrupting the flow of a figure-skimming dress and skewing the balance of the whole. 


It may also cause you to walk in a less poised way by causing your spine to bend in one direction and your carrying shoulder to fall forwards.

When shoulder-bags are just right

I rate shoulder-bags highly for day-to-day life as I tend to carry a lot of stuff, but I don’t think they function well in an evening ambience.


You never see a woman on the Hollywood red carpet with a shoulder-bag do you? 



Google it and see.


Clutch or handbag?

The most elegant women I saw going in and out of dinner that evening carried a handbag or clutch-bag, of a size and shape that wouldn’t interfere with the impact of the overall outfit.



No ‘It’ bags. Smart accessories but not loud, so you focused on the woman not her bag.


My years dating as a divorcée

Going on dates as a new divorcée, I felt I needed a lot of things with me and a handbag or clutch wouldn't be big enough to contain them. 


So I ended up packing them all into a sturdy shoulder-bag which probably knocked a few points off my total look.

Style-improv

Meanwhile back in the present-day luxury hotel I realised I had forgotten to pack my posh handbag and didn’t have a clutch-bag.



Then I had an idea.


A woman in a red floral dress sits at a vanity, holding a sunglass case like a clutch, with text asking why she uses it so.

I improvised a clutch by emptying the sunglasses out of their pouch and popping in the fewest items I have discovered I can get away with on an evening out:



  • Tiny hairbrush.
  • Housekeys.
  • Phone.
  • Tissues.


My days of dating ‘preparedness anxiety’

In the past I would have thought it only sensible to carry:


  • Lipstick.
  • Concealer.
  • Blusher.
  • Pocket mirror. 
  • Tissues.
  • Hairbrush.
  • Mild over-the-counter painkillers.
  • Phone.
  • Housekeys.
  • Collapsible umbrella.
  • Cash and cards in case phone technology doesn’t work. 



Sometimes I even carried a personal alarm which in all my years I have never had to use. (Take note and take heart.)


Result: one style-tip and one life-tip

Two realisations came out of this holiday:


  • A handbag or clutch-bag complements an evening outfit better than a shoulder-bag. 


  • Leaving behind 50% of the stuff I usually took didn’t affect the quality of the evening one iota.


This is quite a freeing thought. It makes me realise:


Perhaps I had no need to be as anxious as I used to be when going out?


It’s comforting, even now, to remind myself of that simple fact.


And it did turn out well in the end.


🌱🍃🌿

Like what you're reading?

👇🏻

A pale green rectangular button with a thick coral border, containing the white text
Woman in black hat and green-patterned Agnès B top, holding a hand of playing cards and a drink.
by Katrina Robinson 18 April 2026
Tips on midlife online dating that got me from Devastated Divorcée to Serenely Married.
A monochromatic blue oil painting shows a distant shoreline with faint lights reflecting on calm, hazy water at twilight.
by Katrina Robinson 19 March 2026
?. The comfort zone | When 'the worst' has happened how can you find simple daily measures to survive those first few weeks?
Part 2 of a guide about love life. Phone with
by Katrina Robinson 6 March 2026
A handy guide to why you need to date differently second time round PLUS The books and films that help you make it work for you.
by Katrina Robinson 8 February 2026
Part 2 Of Your (Love?) Life is dedicated to * Reclaiming love and feminine confidence * Often after divorce or heartbreak * Or simply appreciating a feminine boost *
A three-part infographic showing a person’s progress from surviving, to thriving, to passing on what they have learned.
by Katrina Robinson 23 January 2026
I show you ways to comfort yourself when going through divorce or loss, and how the clothes you wear can lift your mood. Katrina Robinson. Part 2 Of Your (Love?) Life.
A person lying face down under a doormat that reads
by Katrina Robinson 22 December 2025
Next in the series: Five ways my Part 2 wedding was different from Part 1
Text says
by Katrina Robinson 1 December 2025
2) Big party or select do? 🎊
A speech bubble contains the text,
by Katrina Robinson 7 November 2025
Learning to shake off the flawed and flaky
Two photos of the same person—a wedding portrait and a headshot—beside a silhouette of a person blowing dandelion seeds.
by Katrina Robinson 25 October 2025
1) Live together or not? 🤔
A collage of Diane Keaton featuring photos of her in hats and dark clothing, with a 1977 New York postmark in the center.
by Katrina Robinson 21 October 2025
In the wake of the sad news of the loss of Diane Keaton (1946–2025), we revisit her standout style persona in 'Annie Hall'
More posts